By Winston Vance
John Cheever’s “The Swimmer,” published in 1964, follows Neddy Merrill, a man who decides to swim home through a chain of backyard pools in his affluent suburb. What begins as a whimsical adventure gradually becomes a surreal reckoning with time, memory, and loss (Cheever).
Cheever crafts a world that appears secure and sparkling at first but reveals its hollowness as Neddy moves forward. The pools grow darker, colder, and more alien. At one stop, he is asked to leave a public pool for lacking identification. At another, a former lover turns him away coldly. His once-familiar neighborhoods feel unwelcoming. The final image, of Neddy arriving at his house only to find it abandoned, captures not just aging, but estrangement and existential vacancy.
Cheever was no stranger to contradiction. Raised in genteel poverty and later living in affluent Westchester, he inhabited the postwar suburban world he depicted and critiqued. His work reflects a deep ambivalence: admiration for refinement and culture, paired with growing dismay at the emotional and moral cost of sustaining appearances. That friction gives “The Swimmer” its emotional gravity. Cheever once joked that his ideal editor would be a man who “sends me large checks, praises my work, my physical beauty, and my sexual prowess… and who has a stranglehold on the publisher and the bank” (Grant). Behind the wit lies a hunger for validation, control, and the security of being seen.
Much has been written about the story’s parody of Homeric epic. Neddy styles himself a hero, christening his route the “Lucinda River” after his wife. But instead of triumph, his odyssey ends in disorientation and diminishment. If anything, Cheever’s true register is not satire but tragedy. While Terence Bowers reads the story primarily as a mock epic that exposes the moral void of suburbia, Cheever’s symbolic language suggests something more intimate and devastating: the erosion of personal identity (Bowers).
Water becomes the central metaphor in this deterioration. The pools begin in “a pale shade of green,” suggesting freshness and vitality, but their hues shift as Neddy progresses: sapphire, then murky, then gold, then icy. Swimming becomes strenuous; clarity turns clouded. Cheever does not simply chart seasonal transition. He renders water as a psychological landscape. By the time Neddy reaches the public pool, “his eyes burned, and the smell of chlorine made him feel sick” (Cheever 733). Sensory discomfort signals emotional fracture. He is no longer a familiar guest; he is an outsider, disoriented and exposed.
The environment turns foreboding. A storm gathers: “The stand of cumulus clouds, that city, had risen and darkened,” and birds nearby organize their song in recognition of what’s coming (Cheever 729). Unlike Neddy, they sense the shift. The natural world, once serene, now becomes an agent of revelation, offering signals Neddy cannot or will not interpret. The weather, the birdsong, the creeping cold—all warn of change, and of the human refusal to face it.
Still, Neddy presses on. His memory falters. At first, he stumbles over names, moments, and timelines. But gradually, the distortions sharpen. “Was he losing his memory,” Cheever writes, “had his gift for concealing painful facts let him forget…?” (Cheever 734). That phrase—gift for concealing painful facts—is the story’s fulcrum. Neddy has not simply forgotten; he has suppressed. His swim is not through neighborhoods, but through years of willful oblivion. The buoyancy that sustained him is denial.
Cheever understood repression firsthand. Though outwardly successful, he wrestled privately with addiction, depression, and deep ambivalence about the life he appeared to lead. His daughter, Susan Cheever, described their Westchester home as a performance: “We had the luxuries of the very rich… but we were tenants, scraping to get by” (Home Before Dark 82; Cheever). This tension, between external grace and internal instability, underpins much of his fiction like a fault line beneath polished ground.
The emotional fracture becomes undeniable when Neddy visits Shirley Adams, his former mistress. Expecting warmth or recognition, he is met with a curt rebuke: “What do you want?” (Cheever 736). The indifference shatters his fantasy that he is still known, still loved. There is no welcome, no memory. Her question cuts through his mirage of belonging. There is no return.
The story culminates not in epiphany but in vacancy. Neddy reaches his home, pounds on the door, and finds it empty. The windows are dark. The place, once his origin, is now alien. The Lucinda River, his self-mythologized passage, has led not to restoration but to erasure. The pools, once emblems of leisure, have become stages of psychic disintegration. The epic frame dissolves. The truth remains: he has been swimming in circles around an absence.
Seen through a modern lens, Cheever’s warnings feel eerily prophetic. Today, the bourgeois ideal has evolved into Instagrammable domesticity, curated feeds, and wellness culture—a smoother, digital gloss layered over the same precarity. Beneath the aesthetic control lie mental health crises, climate dread, and economic volatility. The comfort is engineered. The cost is hidden.
Reading “The Swimmer” is more than a literary exercise. It is an invitation to confront the myths we live inside, the ones that tell us comfort is meaning, performance is connection, and curated identity is truth. Neddy Merrill is not simply a figure of postwar delusion. He is a mirror. His gradual dissolution shows what is lost when appearance replaces authenticity, when self-deception becomes survival. In our world of constant self-staging, Cheever’s vision remains startlingly present.
“When he finds it’s dark and cold, it has to have happened. And, by God, it did happen,” Cheever later said. “I felt dark and cold for some time after I finished that story” (Grant).
So do we.
Further Reading & Sources
Bowers, Terence. “John Cheever’s Mock-Epic: The Swimmer, The Odyssey, and America’s Pursuit of Happiness.” Papers on Language and Literature, vol. 40, no. 1, 2004, pp. 18–44. https://www.jstor.org/stable/40997054
Cheever, John. “The Swimmer.” The New Yorker, 18 July 1964. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/1964/07/18/the-swimmer
Cheever, Susan. Home Before Dark: A Biographical Memoir of John Cheever by His Daughter. Houghton Mifflin, 1984. https://www.worldcat.org/title/18193964
Grant, Jeffrey. “John Cheever, The Art of Fiction No. 62.” The Paris Review, no. 62, 1976. https://www.theparisreview.org/interviews/3390/the-art-of-fiction-no-62-john-cheever
Updike, John. “On Reading Cheever.” The New Republic, 1991. https://newrepublic.com/article/62638/reading-cheever
Leave a Reply